Ajay Krishna S P, Assistant Professor, School of Law, VISTAS, Chennai
Sayana M S, Assistant Professor, School of Law, VISTAS, Chennai
ABSTRACT
The relationship between the Chief Minister (CM) and the Governor in India reflects a complex interplay of historical legacy, constitutional design, and contemporary political dynamics. This study explores the evolution of this relationship, tracing its roots to India’s colonial history, where British- appointed Governors wielded significant centralized powers to maintain imperial control. It examines the impact of key reforms, such as the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms (1919) and the Government of India Act (1935), on shaping the governance framework, emphasizing limited self-rule with strong central oversight.
Post-independence, India’s Constitution introduced the Governor as a constitutional head of the state, acting on the advice of the CM, while retaining discretionary powers in exceptional circumstances. Drawing insights from Constituent Assembly debates, the paper highlights the framers’ intent to balance federal unity with state autonomy. Judicial interventions, notably in S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (1994), reinforced safeguards against the misuse of gubernatorial powers, ensuring adherence to constitutional principles.
The analysis further delves into historical and modern conflicts that illustrate the politicization of the Governor's role, particularly during periods of central-state tensions. Case studies such as the Pinarayi Vijayan-Arif Mohammad Khan Khan conflict in Kerala (2023-2024) and RN Ravi’s controversies in Tamil Nadu underscore the evolving challenges in maintaining cooperative federalism. These examples reveal how Governors have occasionally obstructed state governance by withholding assent to bills,
delaying legislative actions, or intervening in political processes.
This study underscores the need for a redefined equilibrium in CM-Governor relations to uphold the spirit of cooperative federalism. As India’s federal system matures, clarifying the Governor’s discretionary powers and ensuring their constitutional alignment remain pivotal for fostering a harmonious central-state dynamic.
Keywords: Chief Minister-Governor Relations, Cooperative Federalism, Discretionary Powers, Colonial Legacy, Constitutional Framework.
Comments